Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

1. Sketch the distribution

Sketch a picture of a normal distribution. Begin by drawing a horizontal line (axis). Next, draw a normal (bell-shaped) curve centered on the horizontal axis. Then draw a vertical line from the horizontal axis through the center of the curve, cutting it in half. This line represents the overall average of the data and is always located in the center of a normal distribution. Label the line with the value for the overall average and its symbol. The value of the overall average in the example is 10.00 and the symbol for the overall average from the chart is . The example completed through this step follows.

The above article is an excerpt from the “Operational definition” chapter of Practical Tools for Continuous Improvement Volume 2 Statistical Tools.

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

What the chart pairs mean

Variables control chart pairs, which can be creating using SQCpack, illustrate central location and variability.

Analyzing for variability

To look for process variability, study the range, standard deviation (sigma), or moving range chart of the control chart pair. These will show how data points within the subgroup differ from each other. Interpret for variability first. If out-of-control conditions exist here, address them before continuing. Too much variability in the subgroups can be a difficult challenge, but until this variability is reduced, it does little good to work on the target or central location.

To understand this, consider a marksman. If the pattern of shot varies wildly, one time tight and another time loose, all the marksman can do is aim at the middle of the target and hope for the best (see Figure A). If he can tighten up the shot pattern, though, he can place shots to his choosing inside the target (see Figure B).


Figure A

Figure B

Analyzing for central location

Use the average (X-bar), median, or individuals (X) chart to analyze the central location of the process. This indicates where the middle of the subgroup is.

Here the marksman’s shot pattern is tight, showing little variability, but where is it placed in relation to the bullseye? Figure C shows the variability is tight or precise, but there is no accuracy. Figure D shows a marksman whose shots are both precise and on target or accurate.

If you are considering an individuals and moving range chart, keep in mind that you are looking at actual readings from the system, not averages or medians. Individual readings may not be normally distributed for a stable system. They may be skewed if the system is naturally bounded on one side. Characteristics such as flatness and timeliness are bounded by zero.


Figure C

Figure D

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

When do I recalculate control limits?

There is the tendency to recalculate control limits whenever a change is made to the process. However, you should extend the existing control limits out over the new data until you see evidence that the change has had an impact on the data, such as shifting or out-of-control evidence. Then recalculate limits using only data subgroups collected after the change was made.

There are no hard and fast rules for recalculating control limits, but here are some thoughts to help you decide.

The purpose of any control chart is to help you understand your process well enough to take the right action. This degree of understanding is possible only when the control limits appropriately reflect the expected behavior of the process. When the control limits no longer represent the expected behavior, you have lost your ability to take the right action. Merely recalculating the control limits is no guarantee that the new limits will properly reflect the expected behavior of the process.

  1. Have you seen the process change significantly, i.e., is there an assignable cause present?
  2. Do you understand the cause for the change in the process?
  3. Do you have reason to believe that the cause will remain in the process?
  4. Have you observed the changed process long enough to determine if newly-calculated limits will appropriately reflect the behavior of the process?

Ideally, you should be able to answer yes to all of these questions before recalculating control limits.

To create control charts and easily recalculate control limits, try software products like SQCpack.

When do I recalculate control limits? - chart example

See also:
>> Analyze for special cause variation
>> Declare the system stable or unstable
>> What do the chart pairs mean (variables control charts only)

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

Declare the system stable or unstable

Unstable systems

If the system fails any of the tests for control, it is out-of-control or unstable.

If your system is unstable, does the special cause of variation create a favorable output? Does it improve the process? If yes, find the special cause(s) of variation. Try to replicate it and incorporate it into the process.

If not, and it creates a negative output or hurts the process, find the special cause(s) of variation and take steps to eliminate it. After you remove special causes of variation, continue collecting, charting, and analyzing the data. Once the process has been stabilized, consider performing capability analysis to compare how the process is running in relation to its specifications.

Stable systems

If it does not fail any of the tests for control, the process is stable.

If your process is stable, is the data normal distributed? Is it capable of producing output that is within specifications? You may want to create a histogram and perform capability analysis to learn more about your process.

If the process is stable, but failing to meet specification requirements, look for the source(s) of common cause variation. Can these be eliminated or reduced? How can the system be improved?

Note: A process that is currently stable, may not remain stable indefinitely. A new batch of raw material, a new operator, or new equipment, can change the output. Therefore, you should continue collecting, charting, and analyzing data for stable processes.

Capability analysis can be done using software products such as SQCpack.

See also:
>> Analyze for special cause variation
>> When do you recalculate control limits
>> What do the chart pairs mean (variables control charts only)

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

4 of 5 beyond 1 sigma

Note: Use this test for control sparingly. There is a tendency to overcontrol the system when using this test. Use it only when there is some doubt about the system’s stability.

When four out of five consecutive points lie beyond the 1-sigma limit on one side of the average, the system is declared unstable.

4 of 5 beyond 1 sigma - chart example

See also:
>> Any nonrandom pattern
>> Too close to the average
>> Too far from the average
>> Cycles
>> Trends
>> Sawtooth
>> Clusters
>> 2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

2 of 3 beyond 2 sigma

Note: Use this test for control sparingly. There is a tendency to overcontrol the system when using this test. Use it only when there is some doubt about the system’s stability.

The control limits drawn on control charts are located three standard deviations away from the average (or center line) of the chart. These are called “3-sigma” control limits. Sigma is the name of the symbol for standard deviation. The distance from the center line to the control limits can be divided into three equal parts, one sigma each, as shown below. If two out of three consecutive points on the same side of the average lie beyond the 2-sigma limits, the system is said to be unstable. The chart below demonstrates this rule.

2 of 3 beyond 2 sigma - chart example

See also:
>> Any nonrandom pattern
>> Too close to the average
>> Too far from the average
>> Cycles
>> Trends
>> Sawtooth
>> Clusters
>> 4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

Sawtooth

Note: Use this test for control sparingly. There is a tendency to overcontrol the system when using this test. Use it only when there is some doubt about the system’s stability.

The chart below shows a typical sawtooth pattern. Observe how the data points alternate above and below the center line. For some reason, alternate subgroups have greater and smaller averages. Stratifying or splitting the data by key variables may assist in analyzing this problem. This may occur if you alternate samples from two machines or production lines.

Sawtooth - chart example

See also:
>> Any nonrandom pattern
>> Too close to the average
>> Too far from the average
>> Cycles
>> Trends
>> Clusters
>> 2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma
>> 4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

Clusters

Note: Use this test for control sparingly. There is a tendency to overcontrol the system when using this test. Use it only when there is some doubt about the system’s stability.

When clustering is occurring, data appears in groups, even though there is no group of seven points in a row above or below the average. This pattern suggests that the system is “jumping” from one setting to another.

When trying to improve this process, questions should be asked about the transition periods between the clusters. What is causing the system to “jump”?

See also:
>> Any nonrandom pattern
>> Too close to the average
>> Too far from the average
>> Cycles
>> Trends
>> Sawtooth
>> 2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma
>> 4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma

Quality Advisor

Default White Guide

SPC DEMO

Minimize Production Costs, Quickly Detect Issues, and Optimize Your Product Quality

Don’t miss out! Book a demo of our specialized SPC software and unlock immediate improvements in your processes.

Trends

Note: Use this test for control sparingly. There is a tendency to overcontrol the system when using this test. Use it only when there is some doubt about the system’s stability.

Notice that the plot of averages drifts upward on this example, even though there is no group of seven points in a row going up. This pattern indicates a gradual change over time in the characteristic being measured.

See also:
>> Any nonrandom pattern
>> Too close to the average
>> Too far from the average
>> Cycles
>> Clusters
>> Sawtooth
>> 2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma
>> 4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma